The pricing error that cost a hardware shop its margin for two years
A shop adding 35% to cost believed it was running a 35% margin. It was running 25.9%, because markup is on cost and margin is on selling price. The correction was applied selectively rather than as a blanket 14% price rise.
Illustrative figures from a composite scenario — not measured client results.
A hardware and electrical shop in Chattogram. Two counters, around 400 active lines — cable, switches, fittings, hand tools, paint sundries. Family-run, with the owner's son handling pricing since taking over from his father.
The shop was busy and turnover was growing. It also kept running short of cash at the end of each month, which nobody could explain, because the margin was supposed to be 35%.
How prices were set
The rule was simple and had been in place for years. Take the purchase cost, add 35%, that is the selling price.
A fitting costing ৳100 was sold at ৳135. A cable drum costing ৳4,000 was sold at ৳5,400.
The owner's son described this, entirely reasonably, as "a 35% margin".
It is not a 35% margin. It is a 35% markup.
Markup is calculated on cost. Margin is calculated on selling price. They are different numbers for the same transaction, and conflating them is probably the most common arithmetic error in small retail.
- Cost ৳100, sell ৳135, profit ৳35.
- Markup = 35 ÷ 100 = 35%
- Margin = 35 ÷ 135 = 25.9%
The shop was running a gross margin of roughly 26%, not 35%. Across every line, for two years.
Nine percentage points does not sound catastrophic until you apply it to turnover. On monthly sales of ৳12 lakh, the difference between a 35% margin and a 26% margin is a little over ৳1 lakh a month of gross profit that the owner had budgeted for and was never going to receive.
That was the month-end cash shortfall. It had nothing to do with theft, slow payers or overstocking, all of which had been investigated.
How it surfaced
Not through the accounts. The annual statements showed the real gross margin all along — roughly 26% — but nobody had ever compared that figure to the 35% the pricing rule was supposed to deliver. The accountant assumed 26% was the intended number.
It came up when the shop started evaluating POS systems. Setting up the pricing rules required entering a target margin, and the field had a note explaining that margin is calculated on selling price. The son worked through one product on paper and found the gap.
The correction
To achieve a genuine 35% margin, the markup needs to be:
price = cost ÷ (1 − margin) = 100 ÷ 0.65 = ৳153.85
A 53.8% markup, not 35%. The required markup for common margin targets:
| Target margin | Required markup | Price on ৳100 cost |
|---|---|---|
| 20% | 25% | ৳125 |
| 25% | 33.3% | ৳133 |
| 30% | 42.9% | ৳143 |
| 35% | 53.8% | ৳154 |
| 40% | 66.7% | ৳167 |
They did not simply raise every price by 14%
This is the part that took judgement rather than arithmetic.
Correcting 400 lines to a true 35% margin would have meant an immediate 14% price rise across the shop, in a competitive market where several lines are price-shopped against two nearby competitors. On commodity items like standard cable, customers know the price and a 14% jump loses the sale.
What they did instead:
- Commodity lines — the twenty or so items customers price-check — were left alone, accepting a lower margin as the cost of footfall.
- Mid-range fittings and tools were corrected over about four months, in steps, alongside supplier price changes so the rises were less conspicuous.
- Specialist and low-turnover lines were corrected immediately. Nobody price-shops an obscure connector.
- New lines were priced correctly from the start.
Blended gross margin after six months was about 31%. Not the full 35%, but a deliberate choice, with each exception now understood rather than accidental.
The second error they found
While reviewing, they found a related one in their trade discounts. Contractors were offered "10% plus 5%" for larger orders, and staff had been applying 15%.
Stacked discounts compound rather than add: 0.90 × 0.95 = 0.855, a true discount of 14.5%. Small, but it was being applied to the largest orders in the shop, which were also the ones with the thinnest margins.
What we would tell any small retailer
- Say which one you mean, every time. "35% markup" and "35% margin" are different businesses. Write the word down next to the number.
- Check one product by hand. Take the cost and the shelf price of a single item, compute profit ÷ selling price, and compare it to what you think your margin is. Five minutes.
- Compare your pricing rule to your annual accounts. If the gross margin in the statements does not match the margin your rule is supposed to produce, the rule is wrong. This shop had two years of evidence sitting in its own accounts.
- Correct selectively, not uniformly. A blanket rise invites a competitor to take your price-sensitive lines.
- Remember discounts multiply. Two stacked discounts are always slightly less than their sum.
The shop was not badly run. It was well run against a number that was wrong by nine points, and nobody had checked the number because it had always been there.
Calculator Suite — margin and markup, kept separate
Purpose-built calculators for markup, margin, discount stacking, VAT, EMI and compound interest — each labelled so you know which number you are getting. 25+ calculators, offline, no ads, no account.
See Calculator Suite →